Clinical examination is an important part of being a medical student, particularly from year 3 onwards in the UK. As everything medical students do requires a bookshelf to itself, clinical examination is no different. Back in first year I fell victim of my own advice:
Wait until you know which book you need and like before buying any
I say this many times to prospective medical students, it saves both money (quite important!) and wasted space. However, being only a 1st year, I took the advice of my tutor and ran out to buy Macleod’s Clinical Examination, It’s a popular book, no doubt about that. Mention it to most medical students or doctors and they’ll generally nod approvingly. There is a new edition due out in June (on my brother’s birthday, possible present? probably not) which will no doubt be just as popular. Anyone who wants to go buy a copy would probably be best waiting until the new version. I say this not only to gain the benefits of whatever the refresh will contain but also because Student Consult becomes unusable after an update is published.
I kept my Macleod’s happy on my bookshelf for the better part of 2 years. Recently, however, I noticed something funny - I hardly used it. In fact, I was using it less than I was using a similar book from the library. Which book? This one:
Oxford Handbook of Clinical Examination and Practical Skills
It’s a great book. Instead of aimless rambling that I found prevalent in Macleod’s this book is very focused to the detail required. Don’t think this is lacking some of the basics either - each chapter begins with relevant anatomy and physiology which is a very useful summary. I have found things explained here which would take much searching in Macleod’s or that aren’t even there to begin with.
The book is part of the Oxford Handbook Series (like the cheese and onion) and will therefore be familiar to the majority of students. Being a handbook is particularly useful and means it’ll fit in most pockets without trouble.
Still, one of the best features has to be the latter part of the title. Practical skills include everything from hand washing and cannulation to pericardial aspiration and airway management. This is interesting for me but surely could be extremely useful for junior doctors. Don’t try looking for anything like this in Macleod’s, by the way.
To finish of this excellent piece of work, Thomas and Monaghan have included a chapter on interpretation - going through most of radiology, clinical chemistry and not forgetting the dreaded ECGs.
The book is relatively new (May 07) and so far seems pretty scarce. For Glasgow students there are only 2 across campus at time of writing (and none in the SL!). If you can track it down though, give it a glance and see what you think. Not all books are for everyone though, so don’t forget my original advice.
—–
I don’t get any commisson from this book, by the way, despite what it sounds like above. I also don’t get anything from the Amazon links.
—–
In the end - I sold my Macleod’s.
Medical, Review books, clinical exam, Review
Recent Comments